First, a note about the difference between multimedia and hypertext
software.
Hypertext is defined by Huntington Lyman (a secondary English teacher/English
Ed. doctoral student) in his Jan. 1998 English Journal article "The
Promise and Problems of English On-Line: A Primer for High School Teachers,"
this way:
Hypertext, the language of the World Wide Web, allows individual words, strings of words, or images to serve as links. The target for a hypertext link might be a different section of a document or a different document altogether. Hypertext permits a document to be connected to an infinite number of other documents, thus providing the foundation for the metaphor of the Web. While hypertext is most obviously a convenient navigation aid, it has profound potential benefits for language arts instruction. (58)Hypertext software, then, provides a platform for the creation of such documents. The difference between this and multimedia software is one of degree, not of kind. Multimedia authoring software simply adds the ability to import video, animation, sound, and pictures into what is essentially a hypertext document. While hypertext was developed earlier, and thus much of the software is out of current use, these programs offer some valuable tools that are not currently available on any of the multimedia authoring programs reviewed on my Multimedia Authoring Software Review page or the programs on my Web Authoring Software Review page.
| Program | Manufacturer | Platform | Single Copy Price |
| Storyspace | Eastgate | Mac or PC | $195 (e-mail for ed. discount) |
| Thinker | Poor Person Software | Mac or PC | $30 |
| HyperCard | Apple | Mac ONLY | $99 |
| Palimpsest | Western Civilisation pty. ltd. | Mac or PC | $50 (for 12 mo. subscription) |
Program Reviews
Storyspace
This
is a hypertext program that has a feature, pictured at left, that in my
research looks to be unique. This is the Storyspace map, which shows each
hypertext writing space and each of its links. Writers can add, link, and
reorganize by moving writing spaces on the map. What this means is that
as a hypertext document is created, the student/author can see and revise
a visual representation of the overall logic of his or her presentation
during their work. In addition, multiple ways of viewing and mapping the
hypertext, to see both the hierarchical structure and the links are instantly
available, and many views can be kept open at once, as shown here. I am
still in the process of downloading a working demo of this program onto
a Mac, so I have no advice to offer on how easy or difficult this program
is to learn, but it seems easy enough in Eastgate's advertising
material. Storyspace can also translate your document into HTML, which
would then be in a format to upload directly to the Web, or to import into
a multimedia application like Director (reviewed on my Multimedia
Authoring Software page) to add graphics, sound, or animation, or into
a web page builder like Netscape Composer or Macromedia Dreamweaver. I
would love to have this program and will be lobbying my school district
to buy it. Downside: a pretty hefty price tag, even with the educational
discount. They quote $545 for a 10 workstation license or $1395 for a 50
workstation license, not including shipping and handling.
Thinker
This is a basic, low-cost hypertext editor and word processor. If all
you want to do is create text documents with the capability to link from
any word in the text to other parts of the same text, other text files,
other applications, or to mail or the web, then this program should work
well for you. You would also be able to publish your work on the web and
install the software on a network. At $30 a copy, for Mac or PC, this might
be a good place to start if you have older non multimedia computers or
a very limited budget.
HyperCard
A demo version of this program is not available, so I have not seen
it work. I do know that it was the original hypertext program created for
use on Apple computers, and that it still will only run on Macs, which
is a problem for most of us in schools that have switched to PC hardware.
Sorry I can't offer more helpful information on this program!
Palimpsest
This program is similar to Storyspace. I have played with the demo
version (only available to download on a Mac), and I can tell you that
it is not geared toward students. The user interface is text heavy and
dense. On Palimpsest, you can take any text and add annotations, one-way
and two-way cross references, headings, and colors. The major drawback
I can see is that if you want to continue to use the program from year-to-year
you have to update your subscription at the rate of $50 per workstation.
For most of us on limited and unpredictable technology budgets, that ongoing
cost may be prohibitive. If you want hypertext, I would put my money on
Storyspace. Eastgate's marketing seems aggressive and up-to-date, which
portends at least a little more time left to get tech support and/or updates
from them.
Note: These programs represent the best of what I found to be available for use in secondary English at the time of this project (April 2001). For a more extensive, broader (PK-16 and all subjects), and continually updated list of software reviews done by educators, you can go to EvaluTech, a site maintained by the Southern Region Education Board. They also have a page called Other Evaluation Resources which will link you to other educational software evaluation sites, the most useful of which I found was the Florida Educational Software Project.
If you teach in a public school in Georgia, you can check out the UGA Technology Training Center's web site for current information on how you can attend technology training relevant to your classroom situation. Look on your state's Dept. of Ed. web site for a training center near you! (The address is usually www.doe.K12.yourstate'stwoletterabbreviation.us)
Back to my Auburn HOME PAGE
Go to my Multimedia
Lesson Plans