Technical Clinic

Developing a Tonal Concept

     This may not be the first question a lot you would think to ask. I know that in my first few years on the horn I thought I knew exactly what the horn was supposed to sound like. That concept was based on my having heard the eighth grade horns play. When I finally started listening to professional horn players I discovered that there was a whole world of sounds and techniques that I had never imagined possible. Because aural images (things we hear) are so much more abstract than visual images the development of a tonal concept will take some time.

       I will never forget an incident from when I was working on my masters degree. Our horn studio teacher would regularly play recordings of different styles in horn class, and one week we heard Hermann Baumann's recording of the Gliere Concerto. I later overheard one of the undergraduates complaining to a friend about having been made to listen to "this guy that sounds like a euphonium." Far from being an indictment of Herr Baumann's playing, this indicated to me just how far behind this individual was in developing a tonal concept (of both horn and euphonium). When I talked to him about his background I discovered that he had played in bands and marched drum corps for many years, but had not played in an orchestra until that semester. He also told me that he did not own a single recording of any solo horn works. This meant that he had spent about 8 years developing a tonal concept that excluded anyone who was either over the age of 21 or being paid to play. I hope that we would all like to aim higher than that.

     If you are near a big city where you can seek out live performances of orchestral, solo, and chamber playing I strongly encourage you to do so. If you do not have that advantage it doesn't mean that you are without resources. There is a much greater variety of recordings available now from more sources than ever before. Recordings can be purchased on-line from a variety of sources, and the large bookstore chains like Borders and Barnes & Noble have fairly good classical record sections. There are also sound files available directly on-line, but they may be either easier or harder to find since the recemt Napster decisions. 

     There are a few "must have" recordings that have been such a part of the horn world for so long that everyone should hear them, but I think it is also important to hear a variety of sounds and styles from the very beginning. If you have a private teacher, talk to them about what kinds of recordings they would recommend, and for suggestions on how to listen. What appears below is only a starting point. If I've left off one of your favorites, please e-mail me the info and I'll be happy to add it. I have left out some of my favorites, because I didn't list anything I couldn't find listed at a major retail source on-line.

   

Suggested Horn Recordings

Artist

Title/Label/Series Contents

Dennis Brain Mozart Horn Concertos Concerto No. 1 in D major; Concerto #2  K. 417; Concerto #3 K. 447; Concerto No. 4 in E flat major, K. 495.
      This is the highest selling classical recording of all time. It is an absolute must have for any serious horn players record collection. When I searched for it recently on-line the only version I seemed to be able to find was an EMI re-release with the quintet for piano & winds (K. 452) added. The Mozarts are with Von Karajan and the Philharmonia Orchestra. I'm not sure if the original, with just the Concerti, is still available, but if the recording quality is good on this one I see no reason to turn it down because it has an extra piece on it.

Dennis Brain Strauss, Hindemith: Horn Concertos / EMI Classics Paul Hindemith, Concerto for Horn; Richard Strauss, Concerto for Horn no 1 in E flat major, Opus 11; Richard Strauss, Concerto for Horn no 2 in E flat major, AV 132.
     Once again, a standard recording of standard repertoire. It is hard to go wrong with recordings of Dennis Brain.

Dennis and Aubrey Brain EMI Classics Mozart, Concerto #2 (Dennis) K. 417, Concerto #3 (Aubrey) K. 447, Divertimento in D (Both). K. 334
     Actually any recording by Dennis Brain is worth having. I find this one particularly interesting because it includes the Divertimento which he performs with his father.

Barry Tuckwell Horn Concertos / EMI Classics (compilation of several previous recordings) G. P. Telemann, Concerto in D; Luigi Cherubini, Sonata No. 2 in F for horn; Christoph Forster, Concerto in E flat; Carl Maria von Weber, Concertino in E minor; Leopold Mozart, Concerto in D; Michael Haydn, Concertino in D; Johann W. Stich (Punto), Concerto No. 5 in F; Stich, Concerto No. 6 in E flat; Stich, Concerto No. 10 in F; Stich, Concerto no. 11 in E; F. J. Haydn, Concerto No. 1 in D.
     This is actually a re-release, on 2 CD's, of several earlier recordings. You should definitely purchase other recordings by Mr. Tuckwell, but for those of you desperate to jump start your collection this provides a lot of music in one box.

Michael Thompson Mozart, Complete Works for Horn and Orchestra / Naxos Fragment in E flat major, K. 370b, Rondeau in E flat major, K. 371, Concerto No. 2 in E flat major, K. 417, Fragment in E major, K. 494a, Concerto No. 4 in E flat major, K. 495, Concerto No. 3 in E flat major, K. 447, Concerto No. 1 in D major, K. 412, Rondo in D major, K. 514.
     The 4 concerti and all the fragments on one recording. And another performer whose recordings come highly recommended.

Georges Barboteau, Michel Berges, et. al. The Magic of the French Horn Michel Corrette, Concertos comiques (25): no 14 "La Choisy"; Nicholas Charles Bochsa, Sonata for Horn and Harp: Andante Sostenuto; Georg Philipp Telemann, Concerto for Horn in D major; W. A. Mozart, Rondo for Horn and orchestra in E flat major, K. 371; Mozart, Concerto for Horn no 4 in E flat major, K 495, 2nd movement, Andante; Mozart, Concerto for Horn no 4 in E flat major, K 495: 3rd movement, Rondo; Louis Francois Dauprat, Sonata for Horn and Harp; Paul Dukas, Villanelle for Horn and Piano; Robert Schumann,  Concertstück for 4 Horns and Orchestra in F major, Opus 86.
      Tremendous variety of musical selections and some truly amazing playing make this one of my favorite recordings. It is also important for American horn students to hear other styles of playing and this is an excellent example for someone looking to expand their tonal concept.

David Jolley Adagio and Allegro - German Romantic Works for Horn  Robert Schumann, Adagio and Allegro for Horn and Piano in A flat major, Opus 70; Franz Schubert, Auf dem Strom, D 943/Opus 119; Richard Strauss, Andante for Horn and Piano, AV 86A; Richard Strauss, Alphorn, AV 29; Carl Reinecke, Trio for Piano, Oboe and Horn in A minor, Opus 188; Carl Maria von Weber, Concertino for Horn in E minor, J 188/Opus 45; 
     If you've been wondering where the American soloists are, here you go. This has also become one of my favorite recordings. He also has a companion recording to this one called "Villanelle" featuring the music of French composers.

Sören Hermansson Horn Concertos / BIS Gordon Jacob, Concerto for Horn and Strings; Lars-Erik Larsson, Concertino for Horn and Strings; Seiber, Matyas, Notturno for Horn and String Orchestra; Max Reger, Scherzino for String Orchestra and Horn; Kurt Atterberg, Concerto for Horn and Orchestra.
    I am constantly amazed by the number of horn students who are not familiar with either the Gordon Jacob, or the Lars-Erik Larsson. This is a good chance to hear them both played extremely well.

Richard Seraphinoff (Natural Horn) Cornucopia: French Chamber Music for Horn and Strings Frèdéric Duvernoy, Quartet No. 2 in D Minor for horn, violin, viola and cello; Louis-François Dauprat, Quintet No. 1 in F Major; Antonín Reicha, Grand Quintet in E Major, for horn and string quartet.
     When I have time to compile a more complete listing, this will go on a separate page of natural horn recordings. Until then, it is a good place to start for those of you who are not familiar with what hand horn technique sounds like when performed properly.

Czech Horn Concertos Zdenek and Bedrich Tyslar / Naxos Josef Fiala, Concerto in E flat major for two horns; Frantisek Xaver Pokorny, Concerto in F major for 2 horns; Frantisek Antonin Rosetti (Rössler), Concerto in A flat mojor for two horns; Frantisek Antonin Rosetti (Rössler), Concerto in E flat major for two horns.
     A large body of solo works for 2 horns exists. There are not as many recordings of them as there are of our solo repertoire, but this is a fine example of ensemble playing by the Tyslar Brothers.

     This list is obviously not complete. For instance, it omits 3 of my favorite performers (Baumann, Damm, and Orval) because I couldn't find a current reference to their recordings with which I am familiar. In fact, the short list of those omitted reads like a hall of fame of horn players. Any list that doesn't include anything by Herman Baumann, John Cerminaro, Peter Damm, Francis Orval, Ifor James, Peter Landgren , Ib Lanzky-Otto, or Froydis Ree-Wekre must be incomplete, but it will give you some idea where to start. The issue of orchestral recordings, is simply to long to address here, but it is an important part of your musical training. I also skipped over some fine soloists  who are normally associated with orchestral playing in order to help focus the list a bit. I'll be happy to add another short list, or add to this list, if there is general interest.

   

 

 

Next Topic - I'm Taking Requests.

Return to Technical Clinics

Return to Horn Studio Home Page